GMOs Don’t Feed the World

Image: corn on the cob. Topic: GMOs Don’t Feed the World

Feeding The World Without GMOs from Gringo Starr Productions on Vimeo.

One of the most often touted benefits of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) or genetically engineered (GE) crops, is that they are essential to feed the world’s growing population. There are currently over 8.3 billion people on this planet and expected to rise to 9.7 billion by 2050. If consumption trends continue, in order to feed that many people, we would need to grow one-third more food. 

But GMOs are not the solution—GMOs will not feed the world. 

First, let's look at this argument from an agricultural perspective. 

The vast majority of GMO crop production does not go towards direct food consumption; rather, it is used for the production of animal feed and ethanol. These are crops engineered to withstand, work in partnership with, and self-generate pesticides. They are not engineered to increase yield or face climate-related challenges to growth, such as drought tolerance. There is one variety of corn that has been bred for drought resistance, but it is likely to only be effective in 15% of US corn fields and is not effective in severe or extreme drought, which we are expected to have more of in the coming years. 

Industrial agriculture isn't the answer.  

Increases in yield from GMO crops are a result of a decrease in yield lost to pests from Bt crops (genetically engineered plants that contain a gene from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis), pesticides, and an increase in fertilizer use (made from petroleum, defeating the purpose of ethanol, which is used to offset fossil fuels used in cars). Unfortunately, growing weed and pest resistance is already decreasing their effectiveness, requiring much more dangerous pesticides and making useless one of the most used organic pesticides, Bt. These minimal increases in yield have come with major externalities, including but not limited to water pollution, pollinator loss, and soil degradation, that put future food security at risk. After decades of attempts, Big Biotech has not been successful in breeding GMO seeds that increase yield or reduce water use. Conventional breeding outperforms genetic engineering when it comes to nitrogen use efficiency (the ability for crops to pull nitrogen out of soil, developing a more efficient use of fertilizer, ultimately decreasing the demand for fertilizers) and water use efficiency (WUE). 

Overall, conventional breeding is responsible for most of the successful advances in yield. It also happens on a much shorter timeline at a much lower cost. Industry studies show that it takes a minimum of ten years to develop a GMO crop and nearly $150 million; whereas conventional crops take only $1 million to develop, improvements WUE and drought resistance naturally occur at an estimated 1 percent each year. While Big Biotech develops GMOs in a lab, farmers are improving traditional crops in the field. Due to this drag rate by the time GMO crops are finally released they are actually behind their conventional counterparts. 

Conventional crops could also be more effectively bred to work in partnership with the cultural food needs and geographical climate and soil challenges unique to specific regions. Forcing GMO crops into developing countries with higher existing biodiversity puts that biodiversity and future food supplies at risk by threatening native species and practices. There is an abundance of types of crop varieties (both already in use and wild) accessible to breeders and growers. It is important that we tap into this vast resource to expand nutrient diversity and accessibility. 

Despite the proven benefits of conventional crops over GMO crops, the biotech industry continues to push new GMOs as a solution.  Currently, biotech firms are pushing wheat farmers to adopt a new strain of bio-engineered HB4 wheat that is engineered to tolerate glufosinate, a highly toxic herbicide banned in the European Union because of its links to reproductive and developmental harm.  Green America and our allies are pushing back against HB4 wheat and urging retailers to avoid it. 

The Alternative to GMOs: Agroecology, including Regenerative and Organic Practices  

Considering the changing climate and increasing pressures on, and demand for, our scarce resources, expanding the industrialized system of agricultural is not the answer. Agriculture is already one of the largest contributors to climate change. To sustainability produce the food we will need, we must support a transition to more regenerative, agroecological methods of farming. Agroecology  “is a holistic and integrated approach that simultaneously applies ecological and social concepts and principles to the design and management of sustainable agriculture and food systems. It seeks to optimize the interactions between plants, animals, humans and the environment, while also addressing the need for socially equitable food systems within which people can exercise choice over what they eat and how and where it is produced.” Regenerative and organic agriculture are both forms of agroecology.  

It is essential to look at the entire system and how plants work with one another and their surrounding climates. Regenerative and organic agriculture work to rebuild soil health and biodiversity; sequestering carbon, preventing soil erosion, protecting water sources, and reducing harmful pesticide and fertilizer runoff in the process. They also have much better systems of management for small holders and provide a more balanced diet with more nutrient dense crops. Smallholders already produce 70% of the food produced in low- and middle-income countries. More diversified planting is better for soil health and biodiversity and will better handle the challenges presented by climate change and the damage we have already done to our resources. 

Lack of Equity + Poverty = Hunger  

Hunger is not an issue of agriculture or food quantity, but one of poverty and equity. There is currently enough food in the world to feed 10 billion people. That means that we actually have an excess of food. 

Despite that, there is still a shocking number of people who are hungry, 673 million (the majority of which live in developing nations). More than anything, hunger is a result of poverty. The World Bank estimates that there are over 811 million  people living in extreme poverty in developing countries. Continued hunger leads to continued poverty as those suffering from chronic hunger are unable to perform manual labor (the most common source of income in developing countries) and increase their standard of living. Much of this poverty and hunger is caused by existing economic inequity due to current political systems that favor those with higher incomes. The current industrial food system emphasizes the need for countries (regardless of size) to export food crops despite the local demand for basic nutrients. If poverty and livelihoods are not improved, it will not matter how much food is produced if the poorest, and in turn hungriest, do not have the financial ability to access it. 

While there is great hunger, there is also excessive food waste throughout the world. It is even worse in the western hemisphere; the US alone wastes 40% of its food. In western countries, grocery stores throw out a lot of food and will not purchase unattractive produce. Food is wasted simply because it is visually unappealing or goes uneaten. In developing nations, food waste is a result of a lack of infrastructure, capital investment, and basic necessities. Lack of access to roadways, storage facilities, and basic refrigeration prevents food access and increases spoilage rates. With proper investment and support, these problems could be remedied. 

Despite the hunger epidemic we also have an obesity epidemic worldwide, partly because of poor nutrition, and partly because of increased processed food consumption. Worldwide, most of the expected demand for an increase in food is not based on a baseline need for nutrients, but rather the growing trend of developing countries to adopt the western diet of meat consumption. It takes substantially more calories to produce meat and increased consumption ultimately results in a number ofseveral health challenges. Not only does this require a higher production of animal feed crops, the raising of animals for meat puts a number of stresses on the environment due to the current system of large concentrated and confined animal feeding operations, or CAFOs. 

Hunger is an issue of politics and justice. 

It is a choice that we make as a nation and as group of developed countries. In order toTo tackle these problems of access, we need to drastically change our food system. We need an international system of agriculture that supports food sovereignty, regenerative agroecological farming practices, and food security on a regional and local level. GMOs are not the answer. 

If GMOs are not feeding the world, then what do we do to decrease worldwide hunger? Find out here.